Removal of Copper from Industrial Wastewater and its
Relationship with Wilson’s Disease
Type of article: Original
Keniche Assia 1,2,
Leshaf Anissa1, Kidari
Oussama1,Kadire Mazari1, Khelassi Asma1, Fatoumata
Samake2
1.Maghnia Center University, Departement of Hydraulic, 13000,Maghnia,
Algeria.
2Laboratory of Organic Chemistry Natural
Products and Analysis, University of Tlemcen.
Abstract
Background: Wilson’s illness, or hepato-lenticular
degeneration, is an autosomal passive issue that outcomes from an accumulation of
copper prevalently in the liver and brain. The aggregation is happen because of imperfect biliary discharge of copper.
Current information demonstrates that grown-up people need to ingest about 0.75
mg of copper every day to continue a parity. Because of a hereditary
imperfection, people with Wilson’s ailment cannot discharge the abundance
copper, bringing about a progressive develop of copper in the body. Substantial
metals are the most hurtful of the concoction toxins and are of specific worry
because of their poison levels to people. From this poisonous metal copper,
which has impacts in drinking water on the gastrointestinal tract, yet there is
some with respect to the drawn out impacts of copper on delicate populaces, for
example, bearers of the quality for Wilson’s malady and other metabolic issue
of copper homeostasis.
Method:
We picked as a
characteristic adsorbent in this work the Moringa Oleifera Seeds (MOSs) from Mali assortment, which could be
a practical and earth safe strategy for water sanitization. All examinations
were directed at room temperature, and after being permitted to represent two
hours, the examples were broke down utilizing the
Atomic Absorption Spectrophotometer (AAS). The seeds of Moringa
were set up by taking around 1 g of the seed squashed and blending it in with
around 20 cm3 of water to be decontaminated in three distinct
measuring utensils.
Result:
The different
arrangements after filtration, indicated an expanded thickness in the amount of
copper, which demonstrates the viability of the cleansing intensity of the
seeds of MO. The best consequences of absorption were for 30 min of contact
time. We had half copper evacuation. The impact of contact time is significant
in biosorption investigations to decide the harmony
time required for the take-up of metal particles by the MOSs.
Conclusion:
In this
investigation, the MOS from Mali were demonstrated to be a proficient regular
adsorbent material of copper from fluid arrangements. The limit of the MOS to
evacuate copper relies upon numerous models as; plant assortment and states of
examinations. Our examination is going on the investigation of evacuation
parameters, for example, contact time, pH, temperature, molecule size, sorbent
portion, and introductory metal fixation.
Keywords:
Copper, MoringaOleifera Seeds, Wilson’s Disease,Water purification, Bioremediation,
Sustainable development.
Corresponding author: Keniche Assia,Maghnia Center University, Departement of Hydraulic, 13000,Maghnia, Algeria.COSNA laboratory, university of Tlemcen,
Algeria. e-mail: keniche_assia@yahoo.fr, Tel/Fax :0021343265886
Received: 28
February 2020, Accepted: 09 April, 2020, Published: 05 June, 2020.
Screened by iThenticate.©2017-2020 KNOWLEDGE KINGDOM PUBLISHING.
1. Introduction
Given the current
state of public health and the need to reduce the Carbon Footprint (CF) several
research works have been trying to reuse all types of garbage and residues [1,
2, 3, 4]. This work focuses about the expulsion of substantial metals from
wastewater. Particularly, copper, whose impacts on living creatures can be
devastating. In human beings, copper can cause Wilson’s Disease.
Water is an asset
that is basic forever and is required by pretty much every living being. Water
contamination is a major issue particularly in creating nations on the planet.
The water secured about 71% of the all-out earth's surface and groundwater.
Water is one of the more demandable of all urban and rustic enhancements and
essential for human exercises counting water for drinking and water system,
recreational chances and natural surroundings for monetarily significant
fisheries. Contamination represents a genuine hazard to life, particularly when
the water is a wellspring of drinking and for household purposes for people;
contaminated waters are strong specialists of maladies [5].
This asset is, in any
case, getting restricted in its unadulterated state because of thousands of
synthetic concoctions that have been distinguished in drinking water supplies
far and wide and are considered possibly perilous to human wellbeing at
generally high concentrations World Health Organization (WHO) in 2004 [6].
Overwhelming metals are the most destructive of the concoction toxins and are
of specific worry because of their poison levels to people [7]. Metals and
metalloids with nuclear loads extending from 63 to 200.6 g/mole and densities
more noteworthy than 4.5 g/cm3 are steady in nature [8] .This poisonous metal has impacts in drinking water on the
gastrointestinal tract. In any case, there is some vulnerability with respect
to the drawn out impacts of copper on delicate populaces, for example, bearers
of the quality for Wilson’s disease and other metabolic issue of copper
homeostasis [9].
1.1.Wilson’s Disease
Wilson’s Disease (WD) is a genetic disorder that
causes excessive amounts of copper to accumulate in the body, affecting the
liver and brain. Instead of the body eliminating the excess copper, it absorbs
from food, for people with Wilson’s disease, the copper accumulates,
causing tissue damage.
Common signs of liver disease are
i. A yellow skin discoloration
(jaundice),
ii. Mucous membranes,
iii. Swelling (edema) of the legs and
abdomen (ascites) because of abnormal fluid retention,
iv. Frequency of anomalous veins in the
throat, which may drain,
v.
Bruising propensity,
vi. Persistent
bleeding,
vii.
Extreme fatigue.
A few people with Wilson’s sickness may have just
variations from the norm of liver capacity tests and may show no different side
effects until numerous years after the fact. A minority may encounter genuine
liver disappointment. This stake place frequently in young people with Wilson’s
illness and more women are increasingly influenced. These individuals may
rapidly give indications and side effects of liver illness, as often as
possible identified with sickliness due to the red platelet breakdown
(hemolysis) and mental disarray. These youthful patients may not show the
unmistakable corroded earthy colored stores in the corneas (Kayser-Fleischer
rings).
The patient may develop neurologic (brain-related)
symptoms when the liver symptomatology is hidden. Common neurological symptoms
may appear, and progress with time are tremor, trouble gulping
(dysphagia), automatic developments, talking challenges, poor explanation
(dysarthria), spasticity, discoordination, dystonic stances, and strong
unbending nature. Practically totally influenced people with neurological
indications have Kayser-Fleischer rings in their eyes
effortlessly perceived by an ophthalmologist.
This sickness can cause mental indications that vary
extensively in patients; with manifestations going from gloom to schizophrenia.
It is now and again erroneously analyzed as substance misuse. Vacillations in
character or conduct may occur. Most people harrowed by this disease have
neurologic side effects correspondingly or will introduce them in around three
years (with Kayser-Fleischer rings on their corneas).
Young females may have faulty or even the cessation of
menstruation until the disease is treated because of hormonal disturbances due
to an ill-functioning liver, as it is the case with WD. Unnatural birth cycles
and barrenness are likewise repetitive.
Extra signs and cautioning indications of Wilson’s sickness
may contain kidney stones, renal rounded harm, early joint pain, and other bone
and joint associations, e.g., osteoporosis, the advent of bony outgrowths (aka osteophytes)
on large joints, along with a reduction of spinal and extremity joint spaces.
The examination in [10] reports the case history of a
kid who introduced at 14 months with ascites and was found to have extreme micronodular cirrhosis with biochemical proof of Wilson’s
ailment. In any case, given the seriousness of the pathology and early period
of introduction, the chance of incessant copper harming was explored. It was
discovered that the kid's drinking water originated from a drag through new copper
pipes. The drag water had a pH of 4.4, and after entry through copper pipes had
an extremely high copper level of 675 μg/100 ml. He
in this manner passed on from liver disappointment, and at necropsy, high
copper levels were found in his liver [10].
1.2.Wilson’s Disease
Treatment
The WD treatment is deep rooted. It consists to bring
down the copper level to nontoxic level, and to keep the malady movement, while
attempting to return any existent signs and side effects brought about copper
amassing. Treatment is triple: (I) treatment of suggestive patients, (ii)
upkeep treatment after the copper has been decreased in influenced tissues, and
(iii) support treatment in asymptomatic patients.
Three kinds of prescriptions are utilized. At first, the
substances that dispose (chelate) copper from the body by means of urinary
discharge like penicillamine (or Cuprimine)
and trientinedihydrochloride (or Syprine).
Next, zinc salts to restrain the gut from retaining copper from the food. At
long last, the tetrathiomolybdate forestalls the
ingestion of copper and ties up the harmful blood copper to make it nontoxic.
A mix of trientine and zinc
for 4-6 months can get patients with mellow moderate liver disappointment
successfully. At that point, they may embark on maintenance treatment with zinc
or trientine alone. Penicillamine
and zinc are a subsequent option, yet penicillamine
presents more reactions than zinc. Patients with serious liver disappointment
may require liver transplantation. The ones with neurological problems can do
better with tetrathiomolybdate, which is not readily
available. The second choice may also involve zinc alone depending on the case,
but zinc acts rather slow. Still, it does not worsen the drug catalyzation as it is so familiar with penicillamineand
trientine. Trientine and penicillamine are sub-par choices to treat neurologically affected
patients. This is a result of the continuous occurrence of neurological
intensifying, from which a few patients never recover.
Zinc Acetate (Galzin) is
standard for the upkeep of the treatment for patients.
For influenced people without side effects
(asymptomatic) or for people at first treated with chelating specialists, zinc
acetic acid derivation is utilized to forestall copper retention from the gut.
Zinc treatment is regularly favored in youngsters and pregnant ladies as a
result of restricted symptoms. For some patients, narrow minded of zinc because
of gastric aggravation, upkeep treatment with trientine
might be ideal.
Ceaseless medication treatment observing incorporates
clinical subsequent meet-ups, estimations of copper levels (and zinc levels for
those on zinc treatment) in 24-hour pee assortment, hematological tests to
decide the amount of copper not bound to ceruloplasmin
(otherwise known as free copper), occasional appraisal of liver capacities, and
blood component checks. Standard urinalysis ought to likewise be done in
patients utilizing chelating specialists to look for cells or protein in the
pee. Rehashed liver biopsies are generally not expected to follow the
medication treatment progress.
Discontinuation of medication may cause a fast
accumulation of copper and threaten life. Patients utilizing zinc acetate must employ
its prescription version since nutritious supplements may not be bioequivalent
and may be useless. For some patients, liver transplantation may be the only
way out.
The next Sections will discuss the proposed
technology.
2. Materials and methods
Admission of low dose of copper in the eating routine can bring about
lack, and high fixations can bring about harmfulness. In normal case, there is
a scope of satisfactory admission, which will meet copper necessities without danger
of poisonousness. Largely, copper consumption through eating routine seems to
fall inside this range for the normal person. Regularly, just a little portion
of a person's admission of copper gets from drinking water; along these lines,
drinking water ought not to be depended upon as a significant source to meet day-by-day
copper prerequisites. Then again, drinking destructive waters held in copper
plumbing can bring about copper overabundance, and the potential for copper
poisonousness is a public health problem.
With the expansion of mechanical exercises, copper
expulsion forms have become increasingly significant. The expulsion of copper
from watery arrangements has been done by strategies, for example, compound
precipitation [11], particle trade [12], particle buoyancy [13], electrolytic
techniques [14], turn around assimilation [15], dissolvable extraction [16],
and adsorption.
Figure 1: Drawbacks
of different processes to remove heavy metals and advantages of biosorption.
Adsorption
strategies do offer the most useful strategy for treating water. There still
exists a need to build up a minimal effort and effective adsorbent for the
expulsion of overwhelming metals from wastewater [17]. Biomaterials (i) show great adsorption limit with respect to an
assortment of contaminations (even at low fixations), (ii) don't require any
preparing, being earth inviting/economical, and (iii) locally accessible at
extremely ease. They additionally exhibit specific adsorption for specific
contaminants, for example, metal particles lastly can possibly be helpfully
recovered [18]. Different wellsprings of non-business adsorbents are
schematically spoken to in Fig. 1. A large number of them have been tried and
proposed for evacuation of As (V), Pb(II),
Cd(II) and Hg(II) particles from watery arrangements [19].
Figure 2 : Schematic representation of different sources of
non-commercial adsorbents.
We choose as a
characteristic adsorbent in this work Moringa Oleifera Seed (MOS) from Mali assortment, which can be a
conservative and ecologically safe technique for water cleaning. Moringa Oleifera (MO) grows
generally in numerous tropical areas of the reality where general wellbeing is
compromised by hazardous drinking water [20], and its seeds can be utilized to
treat drinking water[21,22]
.
Figure 3 : Vegetable
materials used: seeds of Moringa Oleifera (Mali
variety).
All trials were led at room temperature, and in the wake of being permitted
to represent two hours, the examples were investigated utilizing the Atomic
Absorption Spectrophotometer (AAS). The seed of Moringa
were set up by taking around 1 g of the seed squashed, and blending it in with
around 20 cm3 of water to be cleansed in three unique measuring utensils.
The chronometer is turned at the time of
addition. The beakers are stirred at room temperature for 30 minutes for the
first beaker and 1h10min for the second and 2h for the third.
In the end, the solution is filtered, and then
analyzed by using the AAS.
Figure 4 : Sustainable water treatment
with Moringa Oleifera seeds.
2.1 MO Seeds Pre-Treatment: Oil Extraction by
Hexane
Oil was removed by using the
Soxhlet in which is found 11.13g seed powder placed in a soxlet with 210 ml of
hexane. The mixture is treated for 6 hours. The solvent is then evaporated
under vacuum. The seeds, after extraction
of their oils, are washed and dried for the removal of copper.
3. Result and discussion
Our initial phase in this work was extricated oil utilizing hexane to
acquire seed cake without oil, because MO seed contains 35–40% oil. The presence
of oil in MO seed affects the coagulant and overwhelming metal expulsion
exercises; hence, MO seed's high oil substance would disable the wastewater
treatment process [23].
The different arrangements after filtration demonstrated an expanded
thickness in the amount of copper, which demonstrates the adequacy of the
purging intensity of the seeds of MO. As the accompanying diagram appears, the
best after effects of adsorption were for 30 min of contact time. We had half
copper expulsion. The impact of contact time is significant in biosorption investigations to decide the balance time
required for the take-up of metal particles by MOS. Watery metal particle
arrangements were stayed in touch while with sorbent for 0.5, 1, and 2 h. The
blends were string with 200 rpm and sifted preceding investigation of the
supernatant with AAS. The adsorption of metals utilizing Moringa
is constrained to the adsorption surface. This is on the grounds that Moringa is a cationic polyelectrolyte of short-chain and
low atomic weight [24].
Figure 5: Concentration
of copper in the different solutions after treatments by the seeds.
It should be noted that even the color of the solution
has decrease proof of the elimination of the copper of the solution.
Figure 6: Solutions
after treatment and analysis.
The outcomes acquired in this examination were similar
with the presentation accomplished in substantial metal evacuation by past
laborers, for example, Muyibi et al., utilizing MOS
extracts [25]. The MOS ability to expel copper from a water contingent is upon chemical
piece of the plant and test state of the procedure. For instance, Subramanium et al. detailed that MO seed cake has had the
option to evacuate copper (Cu) up to 90%. The grouping of Cu after the
treatment was in the scope of the standard drinking water [26]. For other metal
we note crafted by Ravikumar K at al., that report
that the ideal dose of Moringaoleifera watery
concentrate with expulsion efficiencies were 95%, 93%, 76% and 70% of copper,
lead, cadmium and chromium respectively [27].Different
plants can be later joined with different kinds of plants.
The carboxylic acid and hydroxyl groups are introduced
in MOS assume a noteworthy job in the evacuation of substantial metal particles.
The rate of evacuations of Copper were (95%) by the MOS from India. Biosorption can be characterized as the capacity of organic
materials official with overwhelming metal from wastewater. The dynamic
specialists in this plant are glucosinolates and phenolics, which are the practical gatherings that are fit
for securing metals. Biosoption action could be
clarified by the charge-fix system because of low sub-atomic weight and high
charge density [28, 29].
4. Conclusion
In this investigation, the MOSs from Mali was a
proficient regular adsorbent material of copper from watery arrangements. The
MOS ability to evacuate copper relies upon numerous rules as; plant assortment
and states of examinations.
Up to now, various advancements have been created for
the evacuation of Cu (II) from wastewater. Nevertheless, the use of these
techniques has been obstructed by some natural restrictions, including high
capital and upkeep cost, costly gear, high affectability to operational conditions,
critical vitality utilization, or inadequate metal expulsion.
The biosorbent (seeds of Moringa with Cu2+) was treated with 100ml, 0.1M
HNO3 in first with consistent blending for 2 hours to expel metals
from the biosorbent and increment its surface zone.
The arrangement is filtred and the biosorbent was separated with 200 mL ethanol to expel
inorganic and natural issue from the sorbent surface. This was done for 2 hours
30 minutes. The adsorbent pH was changed in accordance with 7 utilizing 0.1M NaOH, washed with refined water, stove dried for around 60
minutes, kept in a hermetically sealed plastic holder and put in a fridge at
4°C to another utilization.
Along these lines, the advancement and improvement of
seeds of Moringa as a characteristic adsorbent offers
numerous particular focal points to numerous nations of the creating scene. It
could be seen as manageable, fitting, successful, and strong water treatment.
Our examination is going on the investigation of
expulsion parameters, for example, contact time, pH, temperature, molecule
size, sorbent portion, and starting metal fixation. In the future, the combination of sustainable biomedical
techniques with cyber-physical systems using wireless sensor and actuators
networks and Nano-robots will make possible to perform localized mitigation and
treatment of pollutants to lessen the massive work of water treatment plants
[30, 31].
5.
Acknowledgments
We
are thankful to Pr.Morad Naoum: Director of Maghnia Center
University, for the excellent working conditions and facilities.We
are additionally thankful to Fatoumata Samake for giving the seeds of Moringa
Oleifera bring back from Mali.
6. Conflict of interest statement
We
assure you that we have no relation with any financial organization concerning
the subject discussed and the material chosen
7. Authors’ biography
Dr. Assia Keniche, was born in Tlemcen
(Algeria). Graduated in chemistry at university of Tlemcen,
Algeria. PhD of Bioorganic and therapeutic at university of Tlemcen
(Algeria). Now teaching and researching
on Medicinal Chemistry. Work on natural derived–products, synthesis,
purification and analysis of new compounds that might used
as drugs, new material and in phytoepuration.
Dr. Leshaf
Anissa, was born in Tlemcen(Algeria). Graduated in chemistry at university of Tlemcen, Algeria. Doctor of catalysis and green chemistry
at university of Tlemcen (Algeria). Now teaching and researching on Adsorption of Acidol Red 2BE-NW Dye from
Aqueous Solutions on Carboxymethyl Cellulose/Organo-Bentonite Composite: Characterization, Kinetic and
Thermodynamic Studies. Influence of heat treatment of
iron oxide on its effectiveness as anticorrosion pigment in epoxy based
coatings.
Dr.AsmaKhelassi, was born in Tlemcen
(Algeria). Graduated in chemistry at university of Tlemcen,
Algeria. Doctor of thermodynamic at university of Tlemcen
(Algeria). Now teaching and researching on study experimental and modeling of equilibrium
of liquid vapor of binary system containing ionic liquids.
8. References
[1] Abreu L.M., Hora H. R. M. ,
Rangel J. J. A., Erthal Jr M. , Razmjooy
N., Estrela V. V., Edoh T., Oliveira G. G., Iano Y.; A Multi-Criteria Modelling For Ranking Co2
Emitting G20 Countries From The Kaya And Their Impacts On Elderly Health. BTSym 2019 Proceedings.ISSN 2447-8326.V.1, 2020, Springer Nature.
[2] Oliveira G.
G., Iano Y., Estrela V. V., Monteiro A. C. B., Franca
R. P., Pajuelo D.; Sustainability Techniques in Civil
Construction. BTSym 2019 Proceedings.ISSN
2447-8326.V.1, 2020, Springer Nature.
[3] Thiagarajan Y., Estrela V. V., Edoh
T., Oliveira G. G., Monteiro A. C. B., Franca R. P., Iano
Y., Razmjooy N., Hora H.R.M.; Digital Garbage Bin
Monitoring System (Dgbms): A Smart Garbage Monitoring
And Management Cyber-Physical System. BTSym 2019 Proceedings.ISSN 2447-8326.V.1, 2020, Springer Nature.
[4] Alessandra
Martins Coelho, Vania Vieira Estrela Joaquim Teixeira
de Assis and Gil de Carvalho (March 7th 2012).
Methodology for Optimization of Polymer Blends Composition, Principal Component
Analysis - Engineering Applications, ParinyaSanguansat,
IntechOpen, doi: https://doi.org/10.5772/37504
[5]
Environmental Degradation Causes and Remediation Strategies, VOLUME 1, Editor
Vinod Kumar, Co-editor(s): Jogendra Singh Pankaj
Kumar, 2020, p.257.https://doi.org/10.26832/aesa-2020-edcrs
[6] World
Health Organization, (2004).Guidelines for
Drinking-water Quality.Vol. 1, Third Edition.World Health Organization: Geneva.
[7] L. S.
Silva, G. Moreira, B.A. Curzio, F.V. da Fonseca, Micropollutant
Removal from Water by Membrane and Advanced Oxidation Processes-A Review, Journal
of Water Resource and Protection.; 9,411-431 (2017). doi:https://doi.org/10.4236/jwarp.2017.95027
[8]Khairia M. Al-Qahtani, Assessment and Treatment some of the Local Seeds
then used in Removal of Heavy Metals, Journal of American Science 2015;11(11).
[9] C.N.Sawyer, P. L. McCarty, G. F. Parkin,Chemistry for Environmental Engineering and Science:
Fifth Edition. McGraw Hill Companies, Inc., Boston (2003).
[10] J.Walker-Smith, J.Blomfield,Wilson's disease or chronic copper poisoning?,
Archives of Disease in Childhood, 1973, 48, 476. https://doi.org/10.1136/adc.48.6.476 PMid:4712779 PMCid:PMC1648447
[11] Y. J.Li,X.
P.Zeng, Y. F.Liu, S. S.Yan, Z. H.Hu, Y. M. Ni, Study on the treatment of
copper-electroplating wastewater by chemical trapping and flocculation. Sep. Purif. Technol.; 31, 91-95 (2003).doi: https://doi.org/10.1142/9789812791924_0059
[12] D. Kozodynska, Cu(II), Zn(II), Ni(II), and Cd(II) complexes
with HEDP removal from industrial effluents on different ion exchangers. Ind.
Eng. Chem. Res.;49, 2388-2400 (2010).doi:
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cherd.2013.01.019
[13] H. Polat, D. Erdogan, Heavy metal removal from waste waters by
ion flotation. J. Hazard. Mater.;148, 267-273 (2007). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jhazmat.2007.02.013 PMid:17374447
[14] A. J.Chaudhary, S. M.Grimes, A combined photolytic-electrolytic system for the
simultaneous recovery of copper and degradation of phenol or 4-chlorophenol in
mixed solutions. Chemosphere.;72, 1636-1642 (2008). doi:https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chemosphere.2008.05.048
PMid:18597812
[15] E. Csefalvay, V. Pauer, P. Mizsey, Recovery of copper from process waters by nanofiltration and reverse osmosis. Desalination.; 240,
132-142. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.desal.2007.11.070
[16] Chang, S. H.; Teng, T.
T.; Ismail, N. Extraction of Cu(II) from aqueous solutions by vegetable
oil-based organic solvents. J. Hazard. Mater. 2010, 181 , 868-872 (2009).doi:https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jhazmat.2010.05.093
PMid:20638965
[17] M.Helen Kalavathy,Lima Rose
Miranda, Moringa oleifera-A
solid phase extractant for the removal of copper,
nickel and zinc from aqueous solutions, Chemical Engineering Journal Volume
158, Issue 2, 1 April 2010, Pages 188-199
[18] Z.Shirani, C.Santhosh,
J.Iqbal, A.Bhatnaga , Waste
Moringaoleifera seed pods as green sorbent for
efficient removal of toxic aquatic pollutants , Journal of Environmental
Management,22795-106 (2018). doi: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jenvman.2018.08.077 PMid:30172163
[19] Thekkudan, V. N.; Vaidyanathan, V. K.; Ponnusamy,
S. K.; Charles, C.; Sundar, S.; Vishnu, D.; Anbalagan, S.; Vaithyanathan, V. K.;
Subramanian, S., Review on nanoadsorbents: a solution
for heavy metal removal from wastewater. IET nanobiotechnology
2017, 11, (3), 213-224. https://doi.org/10.1049/iet-nbt.2015.0114
PMid:28476976
[20] D. B. Kumssa, E. J. Joy, S.D. Young, D. W. Odee,
E. L. Ander, M. R. Broadley, Variation in the mineral
element concentration of Moringaoleifera lam. and M. stenopetala (Bak. F.) cuf.: Role in human nutrition. PLoS
One.; 12, 175503 (2017).doi:
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0175503 PMid:28388674 PMCid:PMC5384779
[21] B. A. Nordmark, T. M.
Bechtel, J. K. Riley, D. Velegol, S. B. Velegol, T.M. Przybycien, R. D.
Tilton, Moringaoleifera Seed Protein Adsorption to
Silica: Effects of Water Hardness, Fractionation, and Fatty Acid Extraction,
Langmuir.; 34, 4852−4860 (2018).doi: https://doi.org/10.1021/acs.langmuir.8b00191 PMid:29566490
[22] K. Shebek, A. B. Schantz, I. Sines, K. Lauser, S. Velegol, M. Kumar, The flocculating cationic polypetide from moringaoleifera
seeds damages bacterial cell membranes by causing membrane fusion.Langmuir.;
31, 4496 −4502 (2015).doi: https://doi.org/10.1021/acs.langmuir.5b00015 PMid:25845029
[23] T.C.Shan, M.AlMatar,
E.A. Makky, E.N. Ali, The use of Moringaoleifera
seed as a natural coagulant for wastewater treatment and heavy metals removalAppl Water Sci.;7, 1369-1376 (2017). doi: https://doi.org/10.1007/s13201-016-0499-8
[24] S.A. Muyibi, M. M. J.
M. Noor, T. K. Leong, L.H. Loon, Effects of oil extraction from Moringaoleifera seed on Coagulation of Turbid water.
International Journal of Environmental Studies.; 59, 243-254 (2002).doi: https://doi.org/10.1080/00207230210924
[25] S.A. Muyibi, E.S.M.
Ameen, M.M.J.M. Noor, F.R. Ahmadum, Bench Scale
Studies for Pre-treatment of Sanitary Landfill Leachate with Moringaoleifera seed Extract. International Journal of
Environmental Studies.;59, 513-535 (2002).doi:
https://doi.org/10.1080/00207230212731
[26] S.Subramanium, N.Vikashni,
M. Matakite,Moringaoleifera and other local seeds in
water purification in developing countries.,Res J Chem Environ.; 15, 135-138 (2011).
[27].Ravikumar K., Prof.Sheeja A.K., Heavy Metal Removal from Water using Moringaoleifera Seed Coagulant and Double Filtration, International
Journal of Scientific & Engineering Research, 2013, 4, 2229-5518.
[28] K.Jiraungkoorskul, W.Jiraungkoorskul,Moringaoleifera: A new challenge reducing
heavy metal toxicity: A review Indian J. Agric. Res.;50, 199-205 (2016). https://doi.org/10.18805/ijare.v0iOF.9361
[29] C.Mudenur, L.G.Sorokhaibam,
V.Bhandari, S.Raja, V.V. Ranade, Green approach to Dye Wastewater Treatment using Biocoagulants, ACS Sustainable Chem. Eng.;4, 2495-2507
(2016). doi: https://doi.org/10.1021/acssuschemeng.5b01553
[30] Estrela, V. V., A. C. B. Monteiro, R. P. França, Y. Iano, A. KHELASSI, and
N. Razmjooy. "Health 4.0: Applications,
Management, Technologies and Review". Medical Technologies Journal, Vol.
2, no. 4, Jan. 2019, pp. 262-76, doi: https://doi.org/10.26415/2572-004X-vol2iss4p262-276
[31] Estrela,
V.V.; Saotome, O.; Loschi,
H.J.; Hemanth, J.; Farfan,
W.S.; Aroma, J.; Saravanan, C.; Grata, E.G.H.
Emergency Response Cyber-Physical Framework for Landslide Avoidance with
Sustainable Electronics. Technologies, 2018, 6, 42. doi:
https://doi.org/10.26415/2572-004X-vol2iss4p262-276